Best Italian Restaurants in Toronto (2026)
The best italian restaurants in Toronto right now are Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Square One (Mississauga, $, 4.7★); Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Oakville (Oakville, $, 4.7★); Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Richmond Hill (Richmond Hill, $, 4.6★). eatsTO tracks 187 matching spots across the Toronto area and ranks them by Google rating weighted by review volume — no paid placements. Last verified 2026-09-07.
Every italian spot on this page is a real, open restaurant in the Toronto area, pulled from our live database and ranked by rating and how many people have reviewed it. No paid placements, no filler.
Updated 2026-09-07 · 187 spots tracked · showing the top 24.
The list
- Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Square One — Mississauga · $ · 4.7★ (17858 reviews) · italian
- Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Oakville — Oakville · $ · 4.7★ (10998 reviews) · italian
- Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Richmond Hill — Richmond Hill · $ · 4.6★ (13460 reviews) · italian
- Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Front Street — Toronto · $ · 4.6★ (12591 reviews) · italian
- Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar — Burlington · $ · 4.8★ (6761 reviews) · italian
- Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar — Burlington · $ · 4.8★ (6761 reviews) · italian
- Dal Moro's Square One | Fresh Pasta To Go — Mississauga · $ · 4.8★ (6421 reviews) · italian
- Dal Moro's Square One | Fresh Pasta To Go — Mississauga · $ · 4.8★ (6421 reviews) · italian
- The Old Spaghetti Factory — Toronto · $ · 4.4★ (14008 reviews) · italian
- Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Scarborough — Scarborough · $ · 4.5★ (8974 reviews) · italian
- Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Barrie — Barrie · $ · 4.8★ (4469 reviews) · italian
- Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Sherway — Etobicoke · $ · 4.5★ (7652 reviews) · italian
- East Side Mario's — Milton · $ · 4.6★ (6001 reviews) · Restaurant
- Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Whitby — Whitby · $ · 4.7★ (4632 reviews) · italian
- Dal Moro’s Upper Canada Mall | Fresh Pasta To Go — Newmarket · $ · 4.9★ (2303 reviews) · fast food
- Kara Mia Restaurant - Italian Steakhouse — Oakville · $ · 4.7★ (3153 reviews) · italian
- East Side Mario's — Burlington · $ · 4.5★ (4221 reviews) · Restaurant
- Pie Bar — Toronto · $ · 4.5★ (4153 reviews) · pizza
- East Side Mario's — Oshawa · $ · 4.5★ (3886 reviews) · Restaurant
- Gusto 101 — Toronto · $ · 4.3★ (5677 reviews) · italian
- Fresca Pizza and Pasta — Toronto · $ · 4.6★ (2751 reviews) · pizza
- Mr. Singh's Pizza Bramalea/Orenda — Brampton · $ · 4.9★ (1684 reviews) · pizza
- The Olive Press — Oakville · $ · 4.5★ (3115 reviews) · italian
- Pizzeria Libretto - University — Toronto · $ · 4.4★ (3658 reviews) · pizza
Common questions
What's the best italian restaurant in Toronto?
Our top-ranked pick is Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Square One in Mississauga, based on a 4.7 rating from 17858+ reviews.
How many italian restaurants are on this list?
187 across the Toronto area, showing the top 24 on this page.
How is this list ranked?
We combine Google review score with review volume so a 4.9 with 3 reviews doesn't outrank a 4.6 with 2,000. No paid placements.
Can eatsTO plan a night around one of these?
Yes — open the app and hit "Plan my night" or "Decide for me" and we'll build the whole evening (dinner + drinks + dessert) around the vibe you want.